Major Win for the Planet: Closing of a Wasteful Trade Loophole
De Minimis Loophole
Shein, a Chinese fast-fashion giant, has rapidly become one of the most popular online retailers, particularly among young consumers. Its business model revolves around quickly producing massive quantities of trendy clothing at low prices. While this may seem appealing to consumers, it has significant environmental consequences. Fast fashion giants like Temu and SHEIN have flooded the U.S. with ultra-cheap, disposable products—most of which end up in landfills within months due to poor quality and cheap textiles. They’ve done this by exploiting the de minimis loophole, which allowed packages under $800 to bypass customs, taxes, and regulations entirely.
This loophole wasn’t just bad for American businesses—it was an environmental disaster. In 2023 alone, the U.S. received one billion packages from China under this rule. With no oversight, factories mass-produced low-quality goods using unethical labor and unsustainable materials, and these items were discarded just as quickly. The carbon footprint? Massive. The waste crisis? Even worse.
Meanwhile, responsible retailers paid billions in import taxes while being held to stricter environmental standards. Temu paid nothing.
The U.S. had one of the most lenient De Minimis thresholds worldwide. For comparison, the EU had a threshold of $156, and Canada at a low $20 for non-U.S. shipments making America the most accessible country for fast fashion to exploit. When you take that and the sheer size and mass volume of people living in the U.S. we quickly became a giant sore on environmental impact.
Excessive Carbon Emissions
Shein's carbon footprint is alarmingly high. In 2023 alone, the company emitted 16.7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide, equivalent to the emissions of four coal-fired power plants. This is largely due to its reliance on air shipping to transport goods from its primarily China-based manufacturers to consumers worldwide. Air freight is significantly more carbon-intensive than other modes of transportation, contributing to climate change and air pollution.
Shein utilizes AI to predict trends and produce just enough items to avoid excess inventory. While this may seem efficient, it fuels a cycle of rapid production and consumption, driving up emissions. Furthermore, an analysis of Shein's sustainability report revealed that the company's emissions rose at almost double the rate of its revenue, indicating that factors beyond air shipping contribute to its high carbon footprint.
Water Pollution and Toxic Chemicals
The textile industry is one of the largest contributors to water pollution globally, and Shein plays a major role in exacerbating this crisis. The fast fashion giant relies on cheap, mass production, which often disregards environmental safety measures. Textile dyeing and finishing processes involve the use of hazardous chemicals such as azo dyes, heavy metals, and formaldehyde (you ever open a brand new clothing package and it stinks? It’s these chemicals) —many of which are toxic to both humans and aquatic ecosystems. When factories improperly dispose of wastewater, these pollutants seep into rivers, lakes, and groundwater, contaminating drinking water supplies and harming marine life.
This excessive use of water depletes local resources, particularly in water-scarce regions where many of Shein’s factories operate, such as China, India, and Bangladesh. In these areas, local communities already struggle with limited access to clean drinking water, and the textile industry's immense demand only worsens the crisis.
Impact on Wildlife
The waste generated by companies like wish.com, Shein, and Temu uses non-recyclable packaging and discarded products, which can have a detrimental impact on wildlife and the environment. Expanding landfills and increased incineration contribute to habitat loss and pollution, affecting both terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems!
Closing the de minimis loophole in the U.S. has the potential to positively impact the climate crisis in several ways:
Shift in Consumer Behavior: Making these goods more expensive, could discourage excessive consumption and encourage consumers to purchase higher-quality, longer-lasting items, reducing overall waste and environmental impact. The argument that it helped lower-income families purchase more goods was just a ploy in allowing these items to make their way to our households, when in reality, due to the cheap manufacturing, items were having to be repurchased at a more rapid pace, both having a large impact on the environment and a large impact on our wallets. Think about it, this mixed with the quick ability to purchase online items due to credit card and address saves on the sites made it so you didn’t even have to be aware of how much you were spending. It became easy to click purchase item without understanding how many times you’ve purchased that item or something similar due to needing it in your life and it continues to disinegrate after a few uses.
Level Playing Field: The loophole gave an unfair advantage to foreign manufacturers, particularly those in China, who could undercut U.S. producers with lower prices. Closing it could help level the playing field, making domestic manufacturing more competitive.
Reduced Transportation Emissions: Increased domestic production could reduce the need to transport goods long distances, lowering carbon emissions associated with shipping.
Higher Environmental Standards: U.S. manufacturers are often subject to stricter environmental regulations than those in other countries. Supporting domestic production could encourage higher environmental standards globally.
Improved Enforcement and Transparency:
Reduced Illegal Imports: The loophole was sometimes exploited to import illegal goods, including those produced with forced labor or environmentally harmful practices. Closing it could help curb these practices.
Many of these fast fashion items contain synthetic materials and potentially harmful chemicals that often end up in landfills within months of purchase. By closing this loophole, we may see a natural reduction in the volume of short-lifecycle clothing entering our waste stream, which could help decrease microplastic pollution and textile waste in our ecosystems.
This regulatory change could encourage more sustainable consumption patterns and support businesses that prioritize quality over quantity, ultimately leading to better environmental outcomes!
Sources:
1. Fast Fashion and Its Environmental Impact in 2025 | Earth.Org, accessed, https://earth.org/fast-fashions-detrimental-effect-on-the-environment/
2. Shein is officially the biggest polluter in fast fashion; AI is making things worse | LAist, , https://laist.com/news/climate-environment/shein-biggest-polluter-fast-fashion-ai
3. Is SHEIN Bad for the Environment? Statistics, Trends, Facts and Quotes - GreenMatch, , https://www.greenmatch.co.uk/blog/is-shein-bad-for-the-environment
4. Is Temu ls Bad for the Environment? Stats and Facts - GreenMatch, https://www.greenmatch.co.uk/blog/environmental-impact-of-temu
5.De minimis loophole closed: How Trump's tariff will target Chinese companies like Shein? 10-point explainer
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/global-trends/us-news-trump-tariff-china-canada-mexico-de-minimis-loophole-closed-how-trumps-tariff-will-target-chinese-companies-like-shein-10-point-explainer/articleshow/117892262.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst
6. The Real Cost of Wish-Cycling for Your City - Waste Advantage ..., , https://wasteadvantagemag.com/the-real-cost-of-wish-cycling-for-your-city/
7. The carbon footprint of streaming video: fact-checking the headlines – Analysis - IEA, https://www.iea.org/commentaries/the-carbon-footprint-of-streaming-video-fact-checking-the-headlines
8. The Ethical and Sustainability Concerns of Temu and Shein - Me Mother Earth, https://memotherearthbrand.com/blogs/plastic-free-living/the-ethical-and-sustainability-concerns-of-temu-and-shein
9. How can we reduce our Fashion Environmental Impact — SustainYourStyle, https://www.sustainyourstyle.org/en/reducing-our-impact
10. The Environmental Impact Of Fast Fashion And How To Reduce It - Tru Earth https://tru.earth/blogs/tru-living/environmental-impact-of-fast-fashion-and-how-to-reduce-it
11.De Minimis: A Vital Tax Exemption https://www.nftc.org/de-minimis-a-vital-tax-exemption/
12.
